Too Much Extra Junk on Blog Posts

Marketing guru Seth Godin blogged today about adding some fancy new links on his site.

First, he added this little pop up thing next to his books. It’s not a true pop up window (it’s all web 2.0–what is that? Java? Ruby on Rails?) but it gives you a number of link options. You can buy the book on Amazon or Barnes & Noble or Google it or do half a dozen other things. It’s interesting. Some what useful. I can’t help but wonder if one more arrow next to his book will confuse people (do I click on the book, the arrow, or the title?). It’s also fairly similar to SnapShots, which I also find some what confusing/distracting.

But second, Godin also added “flair” to the bottom of each post for Technorati, Digg and saving/linking/adding/whatever-you-do-there. I’m so unsure about this sort of feature-creep. I talked about it before, getting some inspiration from Jason Kottke to tone down the excessive information.

I can see the advantage of adding these sorts of tools. You want people to Digg your articles. You want people to save your entry so they can read it later. But how many of these tools can you pander to? (seems like somewhere I’ve seen an example where somebody just added as many of these icons and buttons as possible, to hilarious results) Just the popular ones? Do you swap out popular ones with even more popular ones every few months? And how distracting is that?

I think if someone is going to use a service like Digg or then they don’t need you reminding them to do it. They have the plugins or the shortcuts or whatever they need to do to tag or save or ding your blog entry and they’ll do it their own way without your fancy little buttons. That’s my opinion anyway, but it doesn’t seem to stop anyone from adding all those tools, whether it’s a blogger like Seth Godin or a major newspaper.

4 thoughts on “Too Much Extra Junk on Blog Posts”

  1. Social media “flair.” That’s hilarious! And it reminds me of the problem with flair in Office Space.

    Flair isn’t real. It’s a pretense of personality.

    And now we’ve got the same pretense going on with blogs. Everyone wants to appear hooked up, connected, and linked in. I’m dugg. I’m

    As to the snapshots. I installed them in a moment of lunacy and now can’t remove the code!

  2. The flair was all Seth Godin, and yes, he was referencing Office Space. (and you know what, ‘flair’ is probably the better spelling. Godin used ‘flare’ so I went with it, but it never did look right. I’m changing it)

    A pretense of personality. That’s true. I think it’s also a pretense of promotion. I wonder how much it helps anybody to add all those links? Somebody should do a study on that.

  3. Speaking of extras… Isn’t “too much extra junk” too much?

    “Too much” entails “extra.” So you don’t need both.

    Plus, isn’t junk junk? Can you really have too much, too little, or just the right amount of junk?

    So, TMEJ could just of easily have been “junk.” And that would have been a lot less junky.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.